Heat Pump vs Gas vs Electric Hot Water: Wangaratta Plumber Guideheat-pump-vs-gas-vs-electric-hot-water-wangarattahttps://cdn.prod.website-files.com/69e16de3fc4e1c0b340a80b5/6afa554c1d1ba3a472429a67_heat_pump_landscape.jpgHeat pump, gas or electric? We compare hot water systems for Wangaratta and Benalla homes, covering frosty winters, running costs, rebates and the 2027 gas rules.https://cdn.prod.website-files.com/69e16de3fc4e1c0b340a80b5/6afa580bc59b454c1189e6e5_Photo%20(1).jpghttps://cdn.prod.website-files.com/69e16de3fc4e1c0b340a80b5/6afa554c1d1ba3a472429a67_heat_pump_landscape.jpgtrueWhich hot water system suits your North East Victoria home? Compare heat pump, gas and electric on running costs, cold winters, rebates and 2027 rulesArticlesarticles2022-11-03T15:00:35.850Z2026-04-17T02:02:24.449Z2022-11-11T23:19:28.768Z2026-11-16T01:23:15.637Z
Which hot water system suits your North East Victoria home? Compare heat pump, gas and electric on running costs, cold winters, rebates and 2027 rules

For many North East Victorian homes, a heat pump is now the best all-round hot water choice, mainly because it is much cheaper to run than standard electric and qualifies for Victorian rebates. Gas and standard electric storage still have a place, but the rules are changing: from 1 March 2027, a gas hot water system in an existing Victorian home that reaches the end of its life must be replaced with an electric one.
This guide compares the three options for local conditions, including frosty winters, homes without mains gas, and the rebates available right now. Rebate amounts and rules below were current at 16 November 2026.
A fourth option, solar-boosted hot water, uses roof collectors with an electric or gas booster and also qualifies for Victorian discounts.
Modern heat pumps work well in cold climates if you pick the right model. An ACT Government buyer's guide notes that some units run efficiently in temperatures as low as -10°C, and that a heat pump typically delivers three to four units of heat for every unit of electricity.
What to check before you buy:
Heat pumps cost more to buy than other systems, but lower running costs mean the same guide estimates payback in roughly 4 to 6 years. See our hot water system installation service for options.
Gas systems cost less to buy, heat water quickly and are unaffected by outdoor temperature. If your home has a working gas system, it can stay where it is.
The change comes at replacement time. From 1 March 2027, a gas hot water system in an existing Victorian home that reaches the end of its life has to be replaced with an electric alternative such as a heat pump. New homes must be all-electric from 1 January 2027. Until the March date, replacing like for like is still allowed under current rules.
If you rely on bottled LPG, also weigh up the ongoing cost of cylinder deliveries and refills against running on electricity.
We service and repair gas systems. See our gas hot water page.
A conventional electric storage tank has the lowest purchase price and a simple install. The trade-off is running cost. Its efficiency cannot exceed 100%, so a heat pump heating the same water uses a fraction of the electricity (up to 75% less, according to Victorian Energy Upgrades).
It can suit a small household, a rarely used holiday house or a tight budget. It suits busy family homes less well.
If you rent out the property, note that from 1 March 2027 a rental with an unrepairable water heater must be fitted with an efficient electric model, such as a heat pump or electric-boosted solar system. Standard electric storage may not meet that requirement, so check before you buy.
Two Victorian programs can cut the upfront price of a heat pump or solar-boosted system.
Get a written quote from an authorised retailer and wait for approval before paying a deposit. In an emergency you can install first and prove eligibility afterwards. The installer must finish within 120 days of your QR code being issued.
Rules to know:
A note on timing. These are current Victorian Government policies. The state opposition has said it would scrap the gas appliance ban within 100 days if it wins this month's election, so check the position before you decide. We will update this page if the rules change.
Do heat pumps work in frosty North East Victorian winters?
Yes, with the right model. Some units keep running efficiently well below zero. Ask for a cold-climate model and check how often the electric booster is likely to switch on.
Do I have to replace my working gas hot water system?
No. The 1 March 2027 rule applies when an existing gas system needs replacing, not before.
Who can claim the Victorian hot water rebate?
The Solar Homes rebate is for owner-occupiers who meet the income and property value limits. The Victorian Energy Upgrades discount is also open to private rentals. Both need approval before you buy.
How long does a heat pump take to pay for itself?
An ACT Government guide estimates roughly 4 to 6 years, depending on the system and how much hot water you use. Rebates shorten that. We can quote your actual numbers.
Not sure which system suits your home? Duncan's Plumbing & Gas installs and services hot water systems across Wangaratta and North East Victoria, and we can work out the right option and any rebates that apply. Call us on 0423 212 208 or get a quote online. If your hot water has stopped working, see our emergency hot water page.